Are BuddyNext and FluentCommunity the same kind of product?
Closer than most pairs on this site. Both are self-hosted WordPress plugins with a free core and a paid Pro license, and with both your members and content stay in your own database. The real split is scope: FluentCommunity is community plus a native LMS, while BuddyNext spans community, forums, events, jobs, a marketplace, directories and gamification from one team.
Which has the better free version?
It depends whether you count one plugin or the whole stack. Inside a single plugin FluentCommunity is generous, and post scheduling and analytics are free there while BuddyNext puts them in Pro. Across the stack it is not close: BuddyNext free plus the free cores of Learnomy, Jetonomy, Eventonomy, MediaVerse, WB Gamification and the rest gives you an LMS, a forum, events, media and gamification that FluentCommunity has no answer to at any price.
Does FluentCommunity have a mobile app?
No native app. BuddyNext ships an installable PWA today, and a native app is in development, expected within a couple of months and sold separately. On this dimension neither product has a native app in the stores right now.
I already use FluentCRM. Does that settle it?
It is a fair thumb on the scale. FluentCommunity is built by the same team, so the CRM, forms, email and support integrations are first-party rather than bridged. If your stack is already Fluent end to end, that coherence is worth something real, and you should weigh it honestly against the breadth argument for BuddyNext.
Can I migrate from BuddyPress to either one?
Both offer a path. FluentCommunity advertises BuddyBoss and BuddyPress migration in its free plugin. BuddyNext has its own migration route documented on this site. Whichever you pick, test the import on a staging copy first, because members, posts and media rarely map perfectly between community schemas.